She went on to criticize the well being treatment plans introduced by Mr. Buttigieg (“It’s not a prepare it’s a PowerPoint”), Ms. Klobuchar (“It’s like a Publish-it note: ‘Insert system here’”), and Mr. Sanders (“a good commence, but as an alternative of expanding and bringing in much more people to support, instead his marketing campaign relentlessly attacks anyone who asks a query or tries to fill in details”).
And then she turned again to Mr. Bloomberg in one particular of the most memorable moments of the evening.
The topic was the nondisclosure agreements that workforce of Mr. Bloomberg’s organization signed following allegations of harassment and discrimination dependent on gender. Mr. Bloomberg, in response, had pointed to his hiring and advertising of females, and to descriptions of his company as a superior place to function.
“I hope you listened to what his protection was: ‘I’ve been wonderful to some females,’” Ms. Warren replied. Mr. Bloomberg rolled his eyes.
As the exchange went on, it began to sound somewhat like a prosecution.
WARREN: What we need to know is exactly what is lurking out there. He has gotten some number of girls — dozens, who understands — to signal nondisclosure agreements equally for sexual harassment and for gender discrimination in the place of work. So, Mr. Mayor, are you willing to release all of all those ladies from those people nondisclosure agreements so we can hear their aspect of the tale?
BLOOMBERG: We have a incredibly handful of nondisclosure agreements.
WARREN: How a lot of is that?
BLOOMBERG: Allow me finish.
WARREN: How a lot of is that?
BLOOMBERG: None of them accuse me of doing nearly anything other than maybe they didn’t like a joke I advised. These are agreements in between two events that wished to maintain it peaceful, and which is up to them. They signed those people agreements, and we’ll live with it.
WARREN: So wait around, when you say it is up to them, I just want to be apparent: ‘some’ is how quite a few? And when you say they signed them and they required them, if they wish now to converse out and notify their aspect of the tale about what it is they allege, which is now Okay with you? You’re releasing them on tv tonight? Is that appropriate?
BLOOMBERG: Senator, no. Senator, the enterprise and any individual else in this circumstance — the man or girl, or could be additional than — they decided when they created an arrangement, they desired to retain it tranquil for everybody’s interests. They signed the agreements, and which is what we’re likely to are living with.
WARREN: I’m sorry, no, the concern is: Are the gals bound by becoming muzzled by you? And you could release them from that straight away. Simply because fully grasp, this is not just a query of the mayor’s character. This is also a question about electability. We are not going to conquer Donald Trump with a person who has who knows how numerous nondisclosure agreements and the drip, drip, drip of stories of ladies saying they have been harassed and discriminated versus.
Even before the discussion had finished, some commentators — including the conservative Washington Post columnist Jennifer Rubin and the actor Ken Olin — have been criticizing Ms. Warren as “mean,” “angry” and “nasty.”
But some others noticed it very in a different way.
“I’ve never ever noticed nearly anything like that on a presidential stage from a girl — it was thoughts-blowing,” Rebecca Traister, a author for New York journal and the creator of “Good and Mad: The Groundbreaking Electrical power of Women’s Anger,” stated in an interview afterward. “Look, I located it exhilarating and historic, but there’s no dilemma that it’s a danger.”
It is really hard, Ms. Traister stated, to predict the very long-phrase impact of something that hasn’t happened right before.
Two months in the past on a debate stage, Ms. Warren immediately addressed the strategy of anger and pressure in her concept. In response to a problem inviting the candidates to give a “gift” or apologize to someone else onstage — she claimed she was sorry that “sometimes I get truly labored up, and occasionally I get a small very hot.”